[hoosierglass]

That didn't work. The more I look at this here is the problem:

Order Subtotal is displayed with the following:
{include file="currency.tpl" value=$order.display_subtotal} The value listed here has already gone through an if statement to determine if tax should be applied in the math equation to get to this value. The same holds true if you are in a state that taxes shipping as well. Here is the line:
{include file="currency.tpl" value=$order.display_shipping_cost}

Where can I find the $order.display information?

This is what needs to be changed.