[Jon]

The purpose of this thread was to bring the review to people's attention, and I have no desire to resume arguments that have already plagued too many threads on this forum.

To answer your specific comments, the admin folder issue is the result of a conflict between mod rewrite and cpanel's storing of .htpasswd files in a directory below root. I found it also a problem for online products such as wordpress and popular content management systems. While the issue was challenging an easy one line solution has been developed.

CDSEO and XCSEO work similarily in regard to feed manager and upgrading; you could either upgrade or use the default x-cart urls for feeds which would be 301 redirected.

I do see in the review that it mentions both modules do 301 redirects but can't comment on a lack of alternate criteria.