Don't know if this helps but I just noticed that one of my products dropped off the best seller list when it's stock level reached 0....

Actually, that might help because all my product's qty listing is "0" and I've disabled inventory tracking. I'll try updating the qty to more than 0 and see how it goes. For some strange reason though I get emails saying that the quantity has decreased by one everytime I place a test order. but I thought I turned off inventory tracking??

Dogbyteman, you're the man! That seemed to fix up the problem...it was just a qty error. Thank you very much!

lol @ 'BS List'

*chuckle*

haha.
BS list = Best Sellers List
Recommends List = BS

Since recommends list is just a bunch of random stuff. :P